From Overwhelmed to Effective: Helping a Player-Coach Through Leadership Crossroads

“Stefanie, I feel like I’m drowning.”

That’s how one of my coaching clients—an investment professional at a fast-moving fund—opened our session.

Smart, driven, and deeply committed to his work, he’d recently taken on a leadership role. He was now managing a small but growing team while continuing to produce high-quality work and contribute directly to P&L.

In other words, he was doing the job of three people: operator, people manager, and team builder.

And it was taking a toll.

He felt constantly reactive, unsure what to prioritize, and increasingly ineffective. His team needed more support. His calendar was chaotic. And despite working long hours, he wasn’t seeing the return—in performance or satisfaction.

Sound familiar?

This is the leadership tension that so many people face in what we call the player-coach role.

The Challenge of Being a Player-Coach

Being a player-coach is one of the most complex, growth-stretching transitions any leader can make. You’re producing and delivering results while also managing people, hiring to grow your team, setting strategy, and building systems.

And in fast-paced environments like investment management, the pressure to perform—while developing a team—can feel almost impossible to navigate.

I’ve coached over 50 investment professionals and portfolio managers through this transition. While the industries vary, the leadership challenge is consistent:

How do I stay productive and contribute at a high level…while also becoming the kind of leader who builds capability, culture, and scale?

It starts by stepping back and creating a roadmap, or what I refer to as your “personal leadership playbook.”

The Player-Coach Playbook: A Proven Framework

The framework I shared with my client—and that I personally built and use regularly in coaching—is structured around four stages. It’s not a quick fix, but when used with intention, it builds confidence, clarity, and the leadership muscle required to succeed in this high-leverage role.

Stage 1: Orient to Your Role and Priorities

We began by zooming out. I asked:

What are the three roles you’re playing right now?

1. Operator (doing the work)

2. Manager (leading the team)

3. Builder (hiring and scaling)

He realized he was spending 80% of his time in Operator mode, which left little room for his team—or the systems he needed to scale. We created time targets and identified his top 30-day priorities in each role.

This simple shift gave him language and structure to make smarter choices with his time.

Stage 2: Systematize Your Work

Next, we built out his weekly rhythm.

We mapped his ideal week: mornings for market research and decision-making, afternoons for team check-ins and recruiting. We built deep work blocks into his calendar, established non-negotiables, and got his EA aligned to protect that rhythm.

Small moves like creating a hiring scorecard, documenting an onboarding checklist, and clarifying delegation expectations helped reduce friction and bring consistency to the team.

One of the most powerful shifts a player-coach can make is moving from “What do I need to get done today?” to “What systems will help me lead better tomorrow?”

Stage 3: Develop Yourself and Others

My client had always been a strong individual contributor—but coaching and developing others felt unfamiliar (and it was!).

When we find ourselves in unfamiliar territory, it is human nature to slide back into the familiar – for my coachee, this was part of led to being in “Operator” mode 80% of the time. That was his comfort zone and what led to his success – in other words, it is what got him here but not what will get him there (i.e., successfully operating in this new, larger position).

So, we practiced together.

I introduced him to micro-coaching questions he could use in daily interactions. We established a cadence for feedback. We used a simple, structured framework (Situation–Behavior–Impact–Suggestion) for real-time coaching.

And perhaps most importantly, he began seeing leadership as a way to expand capacity, not just redistribute tasks.

Stage 4: Build Capacity and Scale

As we continued our work, he began interviewing for a new team member. This time, he wasn’t just looking for a fit—he was building a hiring playbook, creating structured interview questions, and involving his team in the process.

We created a 30-60-90 day onboarding plan, set shared expectations, and made space for retrospectives. Suddenly, he was no longer just managing tasks—he was building a system.

Don’t forget to leverage other resources at your disposal in your company. Look to your People Team and Recruiters to help. I can guarantee they have resources and guidance you can build upon and make your own.

A Reflection Discipline to Sustain Growth

Leadership isn’t a one-and-done game. It’s a practice.

So, we built a habit of reflection into his weekly routine—simple, consistent prompts that helped him stay grounded and self-aware:

• Where did I spend my time this week—Operator, Manager, or Builder?

• Where did I feel friction or pressure? What drove it?

• Who on my team is ready for more ownership?

• What do I want to try differently next week?

This reflection loop was the glue. It gave him insight, reinforced what was working, and surfaced blind spots before they became fires.

Final Thought: You Don’t Have to Wing It

If you’re navigating a player-coach role, you’re not alone—and you don’t have to wing it.

The demands are real, but so are the opportunities.

With structure, reflection, and the right support, you can shift from feeling reactive to grounded and effective in your player-coach role.

---

Ready to get these results?

Let’s talk. Contact us to learn more about our leadership solutions.

Want more insights like this?

Subscribe to The Violet View—our monthly leadership newsletter. No fluff. Just actionable insight, straight to your inbox.